September 17th, 2010 Posted in gadgets, review | 2 Comments »

I am in the lucky position that my job required me to acquire an iPad 3G, so to understand the implications of what such a device might be used for, is useful for etc, I have had the pleasure of using on-and-off for the past couple of weeks (about 3 weeks as of writing this introductionary section, in case you were wondering), and let me come out the bush and state immediately, the experience is nowhere near what I had expected…
A little background is necessary, so you can try to understand where I am coming from. I have had iPhones since I obtained a AT&T iPhone 2G, imported it to Denmark and jailbroke it. I have used all the iPhones since then in one way or another, recently less so as I have had to switch my work phone to a BlackBerry (Curve…*sigh*).
I consume (or would like to consume) a lot of music, videos, casual news reading (RSS feeds via google reader as well as traditional news), mail, picture/video taking, facebook interaction and a little bit of gaming on my mobile devices, while on my laptop I mostly use for blogging, in depth news reading via RSS feeds, photo editing, streaming music to my stereo, downloading TV shows/Movies, trying out new applications and generally “staying current” on all things nerdy.
So what does it all mean in relation to the iPad you ask? Well it means that I definitely had some expectations on what it would be useful for, what and where I could see it bring value to me, and where it “fit” in the realm between a smart phone and a laptop, and the last 3 weeks of usage has surprised me. What follows here is a quick brain dump of what comes to find
VALUE HIGHLIGHTS

The things where I have found the iPad to be of tremendous (and well, “some”) value to me worth highlighting are:
- First one is portability due to size/weight and, in no small part, due to battery life. With my usage pattern of checking email, photos, facebook etc on the go to and from work, at home in bed at night, in the morning while eating breakfast, etc, the battery lasts for days. This is where instant-on/off is of real value as the device only uses battery when used. With a laptop I tend to leave it on, or always have it plugged in and turned on, which decreases portability.
- Heat - the thing is not warm-to-the-touch at all(!) – ever – in sharp contrast to my laptop that I am affraid of putting it in a laptop bag before closed completely (no standby!), or any other bag, because I am affraid it can dissipate the heat and will shutdown due to the a heat related issue. It’s happened numerous times…
- Email - General emailing is something that is a drastically different experience from an iPhone/smart phone. The built in mail app is fine, and the Google Apps web application is awesome. The better screen size makes it easy to compose emails that look great.
- Photo Album - as a photo album the thing is great. I recently got married (…thank you!) and therefore I have been carrying a lot of pictures around to all the people I have been visiting during the last couple of weeks. This is truly one of the great usage of the device – a picture bank. I haven’t had the chance to use it a lot for video, but in the limited experience I have – it seems useful.
- Browsing regular websites - I was actually worried that the iPad would not be good for browsing regular websites because the iPad does not support Flash, but it’s better than expected even though it is still not good enough to replace browsing on an actual full blown laptop (at all I might add!) as there is so very many videos that cannot be played. The flash ads, however, I do not miss so much
. The browser (on firmware 3.22) is REALLY unstable though, which frustrates me a lot as it often crashes for no apparent reason.
- Light RSS reading on the go – Reading RSS feeds is verging on becoming useful, where on an iPhone/smartphone, it simply wasn’t/isn’t. I say “light” reading, because it’s still not up to snuff compared to a laptop – although buying the Feeddler Pro RSS reader app does make it work very satisfactory. If using the browser Google Reader interface, browser crashing issue is really annoying. I use the mobile version, because the regular version does not work very well (interface wise) on the iPad.
THE ISSUES

While the above positive things are probably in line what you would expect to hear, what surprised me what more where and when I didn’t find it useful or downright found it a downgrade from using an iPhone or a laptop.
Overall the issue is related to REQUIRED COMMITMENT. Required commitment is related to how the device is used, and in the context of the iPad, while the device has instant-on capabilities and “simple” applications, I find more often than not that the required commitment from my side to use the device is too big to replace my phone when I am in public, and too weak and restricted to replace my laptop at home.
- Before I got to test the iPad myself, I have to confess that I believed that instant-on capability would be a killer feature, because it would allow me to turn-on and off instantly and check up on whatever I wanted instantly, but as it turns out, my wife was right when she told me “does that really matter that much”. I really does make that much of a difference because the device isn’t one you wip out on the street to just check up on things like you do with an iPhone/smartphone device
- Transit to and from work - this was a real surprise, but I don’t find myself using the iPad unless I have sufficient time (+5min), checking news, mail or whatever. I use it if I have to respond to mails, or have a lot of time to catch up on RSS feeds or longer articles.
- While the iPad is very portable, the size makes a lot of things I love about an iPhone type device, not make sense. The quick-check-up apps like when the train is leaving a station, GPS guidance apps, voice-over-IP apps like Fring, stupid-but-funny apps like “Fit og Fugly” and the likes. So the iPad requires a lot more commitment to use, even though it’s portable.
- The right substance for iPad apps has not been established yet. Most are too basic, but I still feel you cannot do the same as with a regular laptop. The iPad is a new class of device and it will take some time for developers to find the right formula for iPad apps.
- News - Even though I read news when travelling to work and other places, doing so on the iPad feels oddly unnatural. The issue is not the device itself I suspect, but the fact that news websites are available in either a small-screen-low-bandwidth version, or the full monty big-screen-high-bandwidth. To me, the iPad falls in-between as a big-screen-low-bandwidth device, which makes many sites feel awkward on the device, especially news sites. I suspect, however, that if the 3G was faster where I use it, or the free wifi in the public transit system in Denmark worked more reliably, regular websites would work ok.
- Where’s the camera? The iPad is an an ideal device for video chat like FaceTime.
SUMMING IT ALL UP
How do I sum it all up? Strangely I wouldn’t want to not have the iPad, even though the usage situations are actually very limited for me currently. It’s because WHERE I use it, and where I find it useful, it’s really really useful to me and there is no device that can really replace it. I also suspect that some of the situations where I find it sub par is due to having getting used to a new routine/usage pattern, so it might solve itself going forward.
Overall, the iPad is a great device that I suspect I will be using in increasingly more situations. And boy do I wish that 1. the browser was more stable and the 2. the thing ran Flash or websites stopped using Flash altogether
.
But most of all, I am surprised that the iPad is more of a souped down laptop than a soup up iPhone/smart phone, and thus it is more likely to end up replacing my laptop than an iPhone – although it is not ready yet. Maybe in a revision or two it can start being that for some people. Therefore you can expect that if you get one, it will replace more of situations where you use a laptop than where you use an iPhone/smart phone